Benchmark crudes
A benchmark, or marker, crude is a grade that trades often enough, and transparently enough, that other crudes can be priced as a premium or a discount to it. A refinery buying a West African cargo, a producer selling from an Alberta hub and a tax authority valuing royalty barrels will all start from one of a small number of reference prices.
| Benchmark | Main market | Quality | Price reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brent | Europe, Africa and much of world trade | Light, sweet | Dated Brent physical assessments; ICE Brent futures |
| WTI | North America | Light, sweet | NYMEX futures delivered at Cushing, Oklahoma |
| Dubai / Oman | Middle Eastern crude sold to Asia | Medium, sour | Physical assessments and Oman futures |
| Murban | Abu Dhabi crude sold to Asia | Light | ICE Futures Abu Dhabi |
| WCS | Canadian heavy crude | Heavy, sour | Differential to WTI at Hardisty, Alberta |
"Dated Brent" is the price of physical North Sea cargoes loading in a forward window of roughly ten days to a month. Because production from the original Brent field has declined, the assessment now draws on a basket of North Sea grades (Brent, Forties, Oseberg, Ekofisk and Troll) and, since 2023, WTI Midland crude delivered into Europe.
Quality and location differentials
No two crude oils are the same. A refiner will pay more for a crude that yields more high-value products for less processing, and less for one that is expensive to deliver or difficult to refine.
Quality
- API gravity. Lighter crudes (higher API gravity) yield more gasoline, jet fuel and diesel and usually command a premium.
- Sulfur content. "Sweet" crudes contain little sulfur and "sour" crudes contain more. Sulfur has to be removed to meet fuel specifications, which costs money, and tighter rules such as the 0.5% global sulfur cap on marine fuel introduced in 2020 affect how much sour grades are discounted.
- Other properties. Acidity (total acid number), metals such as vanadium and nickel, pour point and the full distillation yield, all recorded in a crude assay, can move the price.
Location
A crude that sits far from refineries is worth less at its source than at its destination. Freight, insurance, pipeline tolls and losses in transit are all deducted. When pipelines or ports are congested, the discount can widen sharply, because barrels that cannot move have to be sold to whoever can take them.
Netback pricing. The value of a crude at its source is the price it fetches at the destination minus the cost of getting it there: freight, insurance, pipeline tariffs, terminal fees and losses. Producers use netbacks to compare which market pays best for their barrels.
Futures and physical markets
Oil trades in two connected markets. Futures are standardised contracts traded on exchanges such as NYMEX and ICE. NYMEX WTI futures are physically delivered at Cushing, Oklahoma, while ICE Brent futures are cash-settled against an index. Most futures positions are closed before expiry: the contracts exist for hedging and price discovery rather than for moving oil.
Physical or "wet" barrels, meaning cargoes and pipeline volumes, trade bilaterally between producers, traders and refiners, usually priced as a differential to a benchmark. The two markets are tied together by instruments such as the exchange of futures for physical (EFP), which swaps a futures position for a physical one.
The link between the markets is also why storage matters. In April 2020, with demand collapsing and tanks at Cushing close to full, the expiring WTI futures contract briefly settled below zero: holders who could not take delivery paid others to take the obligation off their hands.
Price reporting agencies
Most physical crude trades privately, so there is no exchange price for a North Sea cargo or a Middle Eastern grade. Instead, price reporting agencies (PRAs), chiefly S&P Global Commodity Insights (Platts) and Argus Media, publish daily assessments based on the bids, offers and deals they observe, often concentrated in a short "market-on-close" window at the end of the trading day.
These assessments carry a lot of weight. They set the price in term supply contracts, settle swaps, and are used by governments to value production for royalties and taxes. Since 2012, PRAs have been expected to follow principles published by the International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO) on methodology, governance and transparency.
Term contracts and formula pricing
Most crude sold by national oil companies moves under term contracts, and the price is not negotiated cargo by cargo. Instead, a formula links each cargo to a benchmark:
Cargo price = benchmark average over the pricing period ± differential
For example, the pricing period might be the five quotation days around the bill of lading date. If Dated Brent averages $80.00 a barrel over those days and the grade's differential is −$1.50, the cargo is invoiced at $78.50 a barrel. (Illustrative figures.)
Major Middle Eastern producers publish monthly official selling prices (OSPs), a differential for each crude grade and each destination region. Cargoes to Asia are typically priced against Oman/Dubai, cargoes to Europe against Brent-related references, and cargoes to the United States against the Argus Sour Crude Index (ASCI). Refiners watch OSP announcements closely because they signal how the seller sees the market for the month ahead.
Because the pricing period can fall days or weeks after a deal is agreed, both sides carry price risk between contract and delivery. That timing risk is usually hedged with futures or swaps.
Market structure: contango and backwardation
The prices of futures for successive delivery months form the forward curve, and its shape tells you a lot about supply and demand.
- Backwardation. Prompt barrels cost more than later ones. This usually signals a tight market: buyers pay up for oil now, and it makes sense to draw down inventories.
- Contango. Later barrels cost more than prompt ones, usually signalling a surplus. When the contango is wider than the cost of storage, traders can buy oil, store it (sometimes on tankers at sea) and sell it forward at a profit.
Refining margins and crack spreads
A refiner's demand for crude depends on what it can earn from the products. The crack spread is the difference between the value of refined products and the cost of the crude used to make them. A common yardstick is the 3-2-1 crack spread: three barrels of crude producing two barrels of gasoline and one of diesel or heating oil.
Strong diesel margins, for example, raise the value of crudes rich in middle distillates, so product markets feed straight back into crude differentials.
Pricing oil sands crude
Most oil sands bitumen is sold as Western Canadian Select (WCS), a heavy, sour blend of bitumen and diluent priced at Hardisty, Alberta, as a discount to WTI. That discount reflects three things:
- Quality. Heavy, sour crude needs refineries with coking and hydrotreating capacity, many of them on the U.S. Gulf Coast and in the Midwest.
- Diluent. Condensate or other light hydrocarbons must be bought and blended in so the bitumen can flow, and that cost is built into the economics.
- Pipeline capacity. When export pipelines out of Western Canada are full, the differential widens. New capacity, such as the Trans Mountain Expansion that entered service in 2024, tends to narrow it.
Bitumen that is upgraded instead becomes light, sweet synthetic crude oil (SCO), which typically trades much closer to WTI.
Where data and software fit
Every differential, pricing period and netback depends on accurate operational data: measured volumes, quality tests, tank levels and pipeline nominations. Clean, timely field data makes marketing, allocation and royalty reporting faster and easier to audit, and that is the part of the chain SandApps focuses on.